The Social Media Telephone Game!

by Paul Castain on October 12, 2010

A few months ago someone Tweeted a really cool statistic that I thought would be perfect for a speech I was about to deliver in Houston.

I got a little suspicious when the statistic wasn’t attributed to anyone so I emailed and asked where they heard it. They told me they heard it from an expert on this particular area and I was given a name. I reached out to them and asked the same question and the process continued until someone basically said “I heard it somewhere”.

When I finally found the “somewhere” they were referring to, the numbers and the findings were dramatically different than that tweet I originally came across.

Around the same time, I attended a webinar where the presenter said “Google alerts is now called ‘Giga Alerts’”. I must confess that I felt like a Grade  A   A –Hole because I have referred to them as “Google Alerts” in at least half a dozen blog posts and in front of no less than 1,000 people who have attended my training program.

I decided to look it up and the information was way off base. Google Alerts is still Google Alerts. While Giga Alert owns the domain http://googlealert.com, Google Alerts are still alive and well and guess what . . . they are still called “Google Alerts”!

This kind of thing has been going on for years.

Did you ever hear the one about the famous “Yale Goals Study”? Its been told for years by credible people like Anthony Robbins, Brian Tracy and Zig Ziglar. Even wannabe guru’s like yours truly have cited the study.

According to FastCompany Magazine (who went right to the “University’s mouth” the study never happened!*

I’ve also heard:

Conflicting reports on how long you have to make a first impression

The average amount of contacts it takes to land an appointment

The best day to call a prospect

Some of us will even high tail it over to Snopes to check out the validity of some of these things. At times its like you woke up in a world where it became “The Gospel according to Snopes” . . . and that worries me!

Which brings us to a rather important point . . . We’d better be real careful and check our facts. After all, its only our credibility on the line!

There’s also another lesson we really (and I mean REALLY) need to understand.

We need to understand another reason why this “Telephone Game” of sorts exists.

It exists because of a little thing called “Filters”. Filters are things we have in place that can radically shape how we interpret a message.

A few filters to consider:

1)    How much noise you have going on in your world when you are exposed to the message. This is a biggie. If I’m “multi tasking” and scanning my messages while my attention is someplace else . . . couldn’t that interfere with the message?

2)    How about viewing a message when we’re on the fly? How about the fact that we are all so busy trying to communicate in 140 characters or less, that we might leave out something critical? Don’t think for a moment, that it isn’t happening.

3)    Our opinion of the person sending the message. Example: I might think that your message is just you over reacting again so I decide to discount your message. Meanwhile someone else who I deem as an “expert” says something and I’m ready believe them in an almost “blind faith” sort of fashion. Here’s another example: I see people popping up daily who have the equivalent of about 10 minutes worth of experience. My rejecting of their message because of that perceived lack of experience gets in the way of the message because its filtered by my opinion.

I could go on and on but here’s where all of this gets real interesting.

Either somebody screws up the facts initially and/or these crazy filters kick in and through the wonders of technology I tell two friends and they tell two friends, and so and so on, until the original message has morphed into something so far removed that we all should hang our heads in shame.

Bottom Line: We had all better slow down, research our facts, cite our sources and become more mindful of these filters.

Until then, effective communication remains a hostage . . . along with our credibility!

*FastCompany article, If Your Goal Is Success, Don’t Consult These Gurus, Dec 1996

  • http://topsy.com/yoursalesplaybook.com/the-social-media-telephone-game/?utm_source=pingback&utm_campaign=L2 Tweets that mention The Social Media Telephone Game! — Paul Castain’s Sales Playbook — Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Paul Castain , JobShoots, JobShoots, JobShoots, Damian Thompson and others. Damian Thompson said: Don't always believe what you hear unless it comes from paul of course ;) RT @paulcastain: Social Media Telephone Game! http://bit.ly/9Pk8Bz [...]

  • Chris Yorke

    A guy on the train told me that he heard from a friend that 53% of statistics are made up.

  • Marlene

    Thanks for this Paul. It actually falls quite nicely after reading your Art of Thinking post.
    People are in such a rush and there is so much info out there that we are all so half-a**ed about what we take in. We need to take the time, do the research and think a little bit more.

    Thank for making me think!

  • Rachel Duncan

    Cute Article,Imagine an opinion, a statistic and a grain of salt will get you:0)

  • http://www.thesaleslion.com Marcus Sheridan, The Sales Lion

    Actually P’, we’re all living in the Matrix so none of this is real anyway…..so it’s completely OK to manipulate and make up stats and other BS as we go ;-)

  • Peter Storms

    In the words of Mark Twain (as best as I can recall)…
    “There’s lies, damn lies, and then there’s statistics”

  • http://communicationsteroids.com Tim ‘Gonzo’ Gordon

    In high school I was trained as a journalist – which meant double-checking facts and stories – and that continued as I went into radio news and reporting for years…so in most situations I feel like my BS Detector is usually up and running. Having said that I know it’s easy to quote something that’s unattributed – and ultimately false – without even knowing it. Most of the time you don’t get sussed out, but as you say…it’s your credibility that’s on the line!

  • http://www.yoursalesplaybook.com/ Paul Castain

    Thank you all for taking the time to stop by and comment. Its always appreciated!

    I will be stopping back this evening to respond but wanted to remember my manners in the meantime and offer a sincere “Thank You” for your contributions!

    Rock on!

    Paul

  • Keith

    Thanks Paul …. There’s this yiddish saying that goes something like this, “To a worm who lives in horseradish, his world is ….. horseradish.” We all believe what we want to believe, and WILL believe what suits us at the time, no?

    On 2), I heard yesterday that “rushing” is close to being determined an “addiction” … interesting concept.

    On 3), Is it the message, or the peson giving the message, that holds more water …???

    Thanks Paul … And what if the Lion is right? And we are in The Matrix?

  • http://www.advadminsol.com Erika Glem

    Another thing you need to look into is the true facts when it comes to politics. We are so overloaded with political commercials. Just the other day the news reported that the majority of the attack ads were completely false. Just like anything else you better do your research before you state your facts or make your decision.

  • Stan Piskorski

    Chris – I heard that it was 68% of all statistics that “motivational speakers” use are made up on the spot. Or was it 72%?

    Erika – what’s even worse than political commercials are “news organizations” that deliberately use or parrot misleadingly edited video clips Ask Shirley Sherrod how she feels about that!

    Paul – I’m like you – I like to check the sources. One that I persoanlly checked was the study about the percentage of communication that is non-verbal that is attributed to Albert Mehrabian. (55/38/7) Non-verbal/tone of voice/words that are used respectively. First I bought his book then I called him up to discuss the data. He said that the data was frequently misquoted because the statistics are true in “emotionally charged” communication e.g an argument with a significant other. He did not quote a statistic for everyday communication or sales conversations..

    I echo you Paul…check the facts…check the facts…check the facts

  • Marilyn Johnson

    Paul-

    Some excellent points. You really have to be careful these days since there are so many outlets for information, and a good portion are not factual or have been altered to make a point.

  • http://blog.insideview.com/2010/10/25/20-crm-social-selling-social-media-posts-to-start-your-week/ 20 Posts to Start Your Week « Sales Intelligence Blog by InsideView

    [...] The Social Media Telephone Game! – Paul Castain (Sales Playbook) [...]

  • http://blog.adamoneill.net iAdam

    Paul thanks for the excellent food for thought. It is good practice to be consciously aware of what we are doing in general.

    Btw, can someone confirm for me again what day the world ends?

  • http://blog.adamoneill.net iAdam

    Paul thanks for the excellent food for thought. It is good practice to be consciously aware of what we are doing in general.

    Btw, can someone confirm for me again what day the world ends?

blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: