Paul Castain's Blog

Proof . . . The Ultimate Anti Skeptic Device!

Posted August 29, 2011

There was an interview in The Wall Street Journal  with Tim O’Shaughnessy (CEO of Living Social) where he faced a few pretty tough questions.

Sound familiar?

One question in particular made me reach for my journal because I thought he handled the question brilliantly!

Check it out (please note that I’ve included Tim’s answer that prompted the difficult question so you have the proper context)

Tim: “We just operate our business. If I took what pundits said as gospel, we’d be in a very different place than where we’re at right now.”

WSJ: “Are they right to be skeptical?”

Tim: “You know, we think its strong. We think that we see great growth in things. We have over a million people that have bought from us three times or more. We are increasing our merchant base, our footprint (and) the number of merchants that are working with us again”

Don’t be fooled by that quick paragraph because I’m here to tell you that there is sales brilliance in there if you allow yourself to own the lesson Tim provided!

He didn’t just make a statement or offer a rebuttal . . . the dude offered proof!

In this case he used a fact (a million people who have bought 3+ times) and examples (increasing their merchant base, their footprint and the number of merchants working with them again)

With just these two simple techniques, Tim provided evidence to make his point.

Probably something we could use in sales, huh?

When I worked for Carnegie there was a really cool way they taught us to remember the use of evidence.

“Evidence D.E.F.E.A.T.S Doubt”

“Defeats” is actually a handy/dandy acronym to help you remember the various types of proof you can offer

D = A Demonstration of your product or service

E = An Example such as the example Tim provided in the example of an example I provided 🙂

F= A Fact.

E = Exhibits or Samples (Note if we used an S here it would spell “Defsats” which might mean something dirty in another language)

A = Stands for analogy.

T = A testimonial.

S = Statistic

One final note about offering proof . . . don’t wait for people to be skeptical or even the proverbial “prove it”;  by then its almost too late and it forces you to play a defensive game.

Instead . . . use proof sources proactively to cement trust and add yet one more differentiator to the brand we call “YOU”!

Your turn . . . What evidence do you use to proactively erase doubt?

Subscribe to Paul Castain’s Sales Playbook by Email

18 thoughts on “Proof . . . The Ultimate Anti Skeptic Device!

  1. Love the DEFEATS thing – time for me to jot it down in my “journal” and figure out what I can use from my own business to line up with it!

    Thanks, as always, for sharing, Paul!

    Have yourself a stellar day!!

    Virtually Yours,
    Anne-Marie

  2. This is more important than probably anyone realizes.  Skepticism and complexity are neck and neck in the sales world these days and both can be quieted with solid evidence.  ( Complexity creates tension in a buyers mind that proof can ease ).   Love the model Paul- will share with my sales folks. 

  3. Hi Paul.
    I like the acronym…it makes it easier to recall the options…hope you do not mind if I share that tip with some of my clients!
    Keep up the great posts!

  4. Another great post Paul!  

    I also agree with Mr. McCarthy in that solid proof of competency about your product or service is what the prospect is looking for so they can trust their decision to work with you!Your Defeats Acronym is a great to remember on anyones next call!Thanks!Larry

  5. Not many people like to offer evidence, they prefer to talk theoretically perhaps because they have none to offer. Maybe it’s a habit. When we start things, we can’t offer evidence, we have to improvise and “fake” things work just fine. When they do work, afterwards, we’re just too used to be vague.

    1. While we can’t offer evidence from our own track record, perhaps we can offer industry stats, case studies, examples, stories etc that are outside of our own limited experience.

      Thanks Gabriele!

  6. Excellent! Offering vague references elicits vague commitments.Be specific and cite real examples and real statistics.

    Cheers,
    Marc

Comments are closed.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!
SIGN UP FOR OUR FREE TIPS
… and never miss a beat!
Your Information will never be shared with any third party.
Could Your Sales Use A Little LOVE?
LOOKING FOR ANSWERS?
Ready To Hunt For New Business Differently?
It's Time To Bring Prospecting Into The 21st Century!
Not really! Fries are bad for you but my FREE sales tips are actually quite good for you! Join 90,000 of your peers when you subscribe below!
Free Fries!
JOIN US NOW
Join 90,000 of your peers when you sign up for my FREE sales tips!
Your Information will never be shared with any third party.
Not really but my FREE sales tips are just as tasty! So hit that subscribe button and I'll send you some FREE cold email templates!
Free Fries!

Company Contact Information

Castain Training Systems
(631) 455-2455
Paul Castain, Founder & CEO
paul@yoursalesplaybook.com

Copyright Information

© 2025 Castain Training Systems
All rights reserved.

Website Design by VanHove Design